Google Fights AI Restrictions Amid Search Monopoly Case
Google Defends AI Business Strategy Amid Monopoly Remedies Hearing
At a pivotal hearing in U.S. District Court, Google's legal team worked to shape remedies following Judge Amit Mehta's ruling that the company illegally monopolized the search market. While accepting some restrictions on its search practices, Google is fighting to protect its artificial intelligence business expansion from similar limitations.
The Gemini Bundling Debate
According to Bloomberg reports, Google attorney John Schmidtlein argued Wednesday that the company should maintain freedom to bundle its Gemini AI application with popular services like YouTube and Google Maps. This strategy mirrors common industry practices, including Microsoft's integration of CoPilot across Office products.
Judge Mehta raised concerns that requiring manufacturers to install Gemini AI for access to core Google apps could replicate the same anti-competitive advantages previously identified in the search market. "Wouldn't this create another gatekeeping opportunity?" Mehta questioned during proceedings.
Proposed Remedies Taking Shape
The court has already rejected some extreme proposals from the Department of Justice, including divesting Chrome browser operations. Accepted measures include:
- Mandating search data sharing with competitors
- Banning exclusive distribution contracts for certain products
The ongoing negotiations focus on finding balance between curbing anti-competitive behavior while allowing legitimate business innovation.
AI Market vs Search Market Distinction
Schmidtlein emphasized fundamental differences between established search markets and emerging AI sectors: "The AI landscape shows no indication of monopoly concentration," he stated. "Google Maps and YouTube don't hold monopoly positions in their respective spaces either."
The legal team contends that premature restrictions could stifle innovation in the rapidly evolving AI field, where multiple competitors including OpenAI, Anthropic, and Microsoft operate at scale.
Key Points:
- Google seeks to protect AI business from search monopoly remedies
- Bundling Gemini with core apps remains contentious issue
- Judge balances competition concerns with innovation needs
- Final remedy package expected in coming weeks
