Skip to main content

Judge Tells Musk's X and SpaceX AI to Reveal Apple Settlement in OpenAI Antitrust Case

Judge Demands Musk's Companies Disclose Apple Settlement in OpenAI Antitrust Case

A federal judge in Texas is turning up the heat on Elon Musk's X and SpaceX AI, ordering them to hand over any settlement agreements they reached with Apple in an antitrust lawsuit that also targets OpenAI. The order, issued by U.S. District Judge Mark Pittman, adds a new twist to a legal fight that pits Musk's companies against two of the biggest names in tech.

The Backstory: Collusion Claims

Earlier this year, X and SpaceX AI sued Apple and OpenAI, accusing them of colluding to stifle competition. At the heart of the complaint: Apple's decision to integrate ChatGPT into Siri and Apple Intelligence, which the plaintiffs argued gave OpenAI an unfair advantage in the App Store. The suit alleged that Apple's ranking and visibility mechanisms buried rival AI apps, limiting consumer choice. Both Apple and OpenAI have denied any wrongdoing.

A Quiet Exit, Then a Demand

This week, X and SpaceX AI filed a motion to voluntarily dismiss their claims against Apple—without the option to re-file—while keeping their case against OpenAI alive. In the filing, they said the claims against Apple had been "resolved," but offered no details. That silence didn't sit well with OpenAI, which quickly filed an emergency motion demanding disclosure of the settlement terms.

Judge Pittman agreed. He ordered X and SpaceX AI to provide "any agreement or set of agreements reached with Apple regarding the resolution of the plaintiff's claims," and gave them until noon on September 17 to respond to OpenAI's motion.

What's Apple Hiding?

The big question remains: did Apple make any substantive commitments to make this case go away? So far, neither X, SpaceX AI, nor Apple is talking. The terms of the agreement—if there even is one—are still under wraps. But with the judge now involved, the pressure is on to reveal what happened behind closed doors.

Why It Matters

This case isn't just about Musk vs. OpenAI. It's a window into how Apple wields its App Store power—and whether its partnership with OpenAI gives the ChatGPT maker an unfair edge. If Apple quietly settled with Musk's companies, it could signal that the tech giant is worried about the legal risks of its AI alliances. And if the settlement includes promises about app store fairness, that could ripple across the entire mobile AI landscape.

For now, all eyes are on that September 17 deadline. Will X and SpaceX AI comply? And if they do, will the public ever see what's inside?

Key Points:

  • Judge Mark Pittman ordered X and SpaceX AI to disclose any settlement with Apple.
  • The companies dropped their Apple claims but kept OpenAI in the lawsuit.
  • OpenAI filed an emergency motion to force disclosure of the settlement terms.
  • The agreement's details—and whether Apple made any commitments—remain unknown.
  • Deadline for response: noon on September 17.