Asian News International Sues OpenAI Over Copyright Issues
date
Nov 20, 2024
damn
language
en
status
Published
type
News
image
https://www.ai-damn.com/1732072674568-202005261145140080_10.jpg
slug
asian-news-international-sues-openai-over-copyright-issues-1732072683099
tags
OpenAI
Copyright
AI Models
Legal Standards
Asian News International
summary
Asian News International (ANI) has filed a lawsuit against OpenAI in the Delhi High Court, alleging the unauthorized use of its content for training AI models. This lawsuit could set significant legal precedents for AI companies regarding copyright and misinformation.
Asian News International Sues OpenAI Over Copyright Issues
One of India's largest news agencies, Asian News International (ANI), has initiated legal action against OpenAI in the Delhi High Court. The lawsuit claims that OpenAI has illegally utilized ANI's content to train its AI models and generate misleading information. This case could establish a new legal standard for AI companies worldwide concerning the handling of copyright in news content.
During a court session on Tuesday, Judge Amit Bansal issued a summons to OpenAI, which previously asserted that ChatGPT did not access ANI's website for training purposes. Due to the intricate nature of the issues involved, the court opted not to impose an injunction at this juncture, indicating that a more detailed hearing is necessary. A follow-up court session is scheduled for next year.
An OpenAI spokesperson stated to Tech Crunch, "We place great importance on collaborating with news organizations during our product and design processes. We are actively engaging in constructive partnerships with multiple news agencies around the world, including those in India, to explore opportunities, listen to feedback, and work together."
This lawsuit is part of a broader trend of increasing scrutiny faced by AI companies regarding their use of copyrighted material. Currently, OpenAI is contending with over ten similar lawsuits in the United States, in addition to two in Canada and one in Germany.
OpenAI's attorney, Amit Sibal, defended the company by asserting that copyright law does not protect facts and noted that ChatGPT allows websites to opt-out of data collection. He further mentioned that OpenAI does not maintain servers in India, which raises questions about the jurisdiction of the case.
Conversely, ANI's lawyer, Sidhant Kumar, argued that mere public availability of content does not grant permission for its free use. ANI expressed particular concern regarding instances of ChatGPT attributing false information to the agency, including fabricated interviews featuring a dialogue with Rahul Gandhi, a prominent political figure and opponent of the ruling party.
In its complaint, ANI emphasized that the phenomenon of "hallucination", where AI generates false information, poses a significant threat to its reputation. The agency warned that the dissemination of fake news could lead to public disorder. To address these concerns, the court plans to appoint an independent expert to consult on the copyright implications of using publicly available content in AI models. Future hearings will delve into the technical aspects of how news content is shared across various platforms.
The outcome of this case may influence how AI models are trained and the extent to which copyrighted material can be utilized without infringing on the rights of content creators.
Key Points
- ANI sues OpenAI, accusing it of illegally using copyrighted content.
- The court decides not to issue an injunction immediately, requiring detailed hearings.
- OpenAI faces multiple similar lawsuits globally, with legal issues needing resolution.